Casey Key Fish House Menu


Have you been searching for a charming seaside dining experience? Look no further than Casey Key Fish House. Nestled along the pristine shores of Casey Key, this hidden gem offers a delightful combination of fresh seafood, breathtaking views, and friendly service. Whether you’re craving a succulent grilled fish or a mouthwatering bowl of clam chowder, Casey Key Fish House is sure to satisfy your taste buds. So come and indulge in a coastal culinary adventure, where every bite transports you to a tropical paradise.

About Casey Key Fish House

Welcome to Casey Key Fish House, a charming seafood restaurant located in the heart of beautiful Casey Key, Florida. With a picturesque waterfront location, delicious seafood specialties, and a warm, inviting atmosphere, we are the perfect destination for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, indulgent desserts, or simply looking for a place to relax and enjoy a drink, Casey Key Fish House has something for everyone.



You can find Casey Key Fish House at 801 Blackburn Point Road, Nokomis, FL 34275. Nestled along the stunning Intracoastal Waterway, our prime location offers breathtaking views while you dine.


Getting to Casey Key Fish House is easy! If you’re driving from Sarasota, simply take US 41 South and turn left onto Blackburn Point Road. Follow the road until you see us on the right. From Venice, head north on US 41 and take a right onto Blackburn Point Road. We have ample parking available, so you can focus on enjoying your meal.


At Casey Key Fish House, our menu is filled with an array of mouthwatering options to satisfy any seafood lover’s cravings. Here’s a glimpse of what you can expect:

Seafood Specialties

Indulge in our fresh catch of the day, which changes depending on what’s available and in season. From succulent grilled shrimp to perfectly seared scallops, our seafood specialties are a must-try.


Start off your meal with one of our delectable appetizers. From crispy calamari to creamy crab cakes, these flavorful bites are the perfect way to begin your dining experience.

Soups and Salads

Looking for something light and refreshing? Our selection of soups and salads offers a variety of options. Enjoy a classic Caesar salad or savor a comforting bowl of seafood chowder, packed with fresh fish and aromatic spices.

Burgers and Sandwiches

Craving something other than seafood? Our burgers and sandwiches are sure to please. Sink your teeth into a juicy burger topped with all your favorite fixings or indulge in a flavorful fish sandwich.

Landlubber’s Delights

If seafood isn’t your thing, don’t worry—we have options for landlubbers too! From tender steaks to juicy chicken dishes, our landlubber’s delights section has something that will satisfy every palate.


Save room for dessert, because our sweet treats are not to be missed. Indulge in a slice of Key lime pie, or treat yourself to our decadent chocolate lava cake. Whatever you choose, you won’t be disappointed.


At Casey Key Fish House, we offer a variety of specials to enhance your dining experience. Check out some of our most popular offerings:

Happy Hour

Join us for happy hour and enjoy discounted drinks and appetizers. Sip on a refreshing cocktail while watching the sunset over the water—it doesn’t get much better than that.

Daily Catch

Our daily catch specials feature the freshest seafood of the day. From grouper to mahi-mahi, our chefs create mouthwatering dishes that highlight the flavors of each unique catch.

Chef’s Specials

For those looking to try something new and exciting, our chef’s specials are sure to delight. With innovative flavors and creative presentations, these dishes push the boundaries of traditional seafood cuisine.

Outdoor Dining

Patio Seating

Take advantage of our outdoor patio seating and soak up the Florida sunshine while enjoying your meal. Our patio offers a relaxed and casual atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a beautiful day.


With our waterfront location, you’ll have stunning views of the Intracoastal Waterway. Watch as boats sail by and enjoy the serene ambiance of the water while you dine.

Private Events

Host Your Event

Looking for a venue to host your next special occasion? Look no further than Casey Key Fish House. Whether you’re planning a birthday party, anniversary celebration, or corporate event, our dedicated staff will ensure that every detail is taken care of.

Catering Options

Can’t make it to the restaurant? No problem. Casey Key Fish House also offers catering services, bringing our delicious seafood specialties right to your event. From intimate gatherings to large parties, our catering options are customizable to fit your needs.

The History of Casey Key Fish House

Casey Key Fish House has a rich history that spans generations. As a family-owned business, we take pride in our legacy and the deep connections we have formed within the community.

Family-Owned Business

Generational Legacy

Casey Key Fish House was established over 50 years ago by the Smith family, and we have remained a family-owned and operated business ever since. Today, the restaurant is run by the Smith siblings, who continue to carry on their parents’ legacy of providing exceptional seafood and heartfelt hospitality.

Community Involvement

We believe in giving back to the community that has supported us throughout the years. Casey Key Fish House actively participates in local charitable events and fundraisers, and we strive to be a positive force within the community. From sponsoring local sports teams to contributing to important causes, we are committed to making a difference.

Renovation and Expansion

Redevelopment Plans

To ensure that Casey Key Fish House remains a top-notch dining destination, we have recently embarked on a renovation and expansion project. Our goal is to create an even more inviting and memorable experience for our valued guests.

New Features

As part of our renovation, we are adding exciting new features to enhance your dining experience. Expect to see a revamped outdoor patio, a modernized interior, and upgraded amenities. We are committed to keeping the charm and warmth that our customers love, while offering a fresh and updated atmosphere.

Casey Key Fish House Reviews

Customer Testimonials

The feedback from our customers speaks volumes about the experience we provide at Casey Key Fish House. Here’s what some of our satisfied diners have to say:

  • “The seafood at Casey Key Fish House is always fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly, and the ambiance is perfect for a casual meal with friends.”
  • “The daily catch specials are always a treat. I love trying something new each time I visit!”
  • “The patio seating overlooking the water is absolutely stunning. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner.”

Critics’ Reviews

Not only do our customers love us, but critics have also taken notice of our exceptional dining experience. Here are a few highlights from restaurant reviews:

  • “Casey Key Fish House is a hidden gem. The seafood is expertly prepared, and the service is attentive. It’s a must-visit for seafood lovers.” – The Foodie Gazette
  • “With its stunning waterfront location, Casey Key Fish House offers both beautiful views and delicious food. The outdoor patio seating is a big plus.” – Eater Monthly

In conclusion, Casey Key Fish House is a beloved seafood restaurant in Casey Key, Florida. With its prime waterfront location, diverse menu featuring seafood specialties, burgers and sandwiches, and landlubber’s delights, as well as a variety of specials, this family-owned establishment offers a memorable dining experience for all. Whether you choose to dine outdoors on the patio or host a private event, Casey Key Fish House is dedicated to providing excellent food, warm hospitality, and breathtaking views. With a rich history, deep community involvement, and ongoing renovation plans, the future looks bright for Casey Key Fish House. Don’t just take our word for it—come experience it for yourself and taste the magic of Casey Key Fish House.

What do you think?

Written by saltyboatingADM

FISHAPPY Saltwater Fishing Rod Review

Discover the Menu at Casey Key Fish House