Casey Key Fish House: A Guide to the Restaurant

Click here to see Casey Key Fish House Menu

If you’re on the hunt for a fantastic seafood dining experience, look no further than Casey Key Fish House. Located in the picturesque town of Casey Key, this restaurant offers a guide to an unforgettable meal. From fresh catches to mouthwatering flavors, Casey Key Fish House is a must-visit destination for seafood enthusiasts. So grab your appetite and get ready to explore all that this charming restaurant has to offer.

About Casey Key Fish House

Welcome to Casey Key Fish House! We are a charming seafood restaurant located in the beautiful area of Casey Key, Florida. With a rich history, stunning location, inviting ambiance, delicious menu, and excellent service, we strive to provide a fantastic dining experience for all our guests. Whether you are a seafood lover or just looking for a friendly and relaxed atmosphere, Casey Key Fish House is the perfect place for you.


Casey Key Fish House has a long-standing history in the Casey Key community. It was founded in 1991 by the Smith family, who had a deep passion for seafood and wanted to share their love for it with others. Over the years, the restaurant has become a beloved local establishment, attracting both residents and tourists alike with its delectable seafood offerings and warm hospitality.


Nestled on the picturesque Casey Key, our restaurant offers a truly idyllic setting for a memorable dining experience. Surrounded by the serenity of the Gulf of Mexico on one side and the Intracoastal Waterway on the other, Casey Key Fish House provides breathtaking views of the natural beauty that Florida has to offer. Whether you choose to dine inside or enjoy the outdoor patio, you’ll be treated to stunning vistas and a pleasant coastal atmosphere.

Ambiance and Setting

At Casey Key Fish House, we prioritize creating a welcoming and comfortable ambiance for our guests. Our interior is adorned with nautical-themed decor that enhances the coastal feel, while the rustic furniture adds a touch of charm. The natural light that streams in through the large windows creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. For those who prefer outdoor dining, our patio overlooks the water, allowing you to soak in the peaceful surroundings while enjoying your meal.


As a seafood-focused restaurant, our menu boasts a wide selection of delectable dishes that are sure to satisfy even the most discerning palate. From fresh catches of the day to tantalizing shellfish delights and indulgent seafood platters, we have something to please everyone. Our chefs take pride in using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients, ensuring that each dish is bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection.

Specialty Dishes

At Casey Key Fish House, we have some signature dishes that have become absolute favorites among our patrons. One of our specialties is the Parmesan-crusted Grouper, which features locally caught grouper coated in a flavorful Parmesan crust and served with a side of creamy mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables. Another must-try dish is the Crab-Stuffed Shrimp, where succulent shrimp are stuffed with a delicious crab mixture and baked to perfection. These distinct flavors are what keep our customers coming back for more.

Seafood Selection

Fresh Catch of the Day

One of the highlights of dining at Casey Key Fish House is our selection of fresh catches of the day. Our chefs work closely with local fishermen to ensure that we always have the freshest seafood available. Each day, the menu is updated with a variety of seafood options, including fish like snapper, mahi-mahi, and grouper, along with seasonal offerings such as stone crab and Florida spiny lobster. This ensures that every visit to our restaurant is a unique and exciting culinary experience.

Shellfish Delights

For those who enjoy indulging in shellfish, our menu has a range of mouthwatering options to choose from. Our steamed Alaskan King Crab legs are a true delicacy, served with drawn butter and lemon wedges. We also offer succulent lobster tails, buttery scallops, and flavorful mussels in a white wine and garlic broth. These shellfish delights are perfect for those seeking a taste of luxury and a chance to savor the sweet and delicate flavors of the sea.

Seafood Platters

If you find it hard to decide which seafood dish to choose, our seafood platters are here to save the day. These generous platters offer a variety of seafood delights, allowing you to sample a little bit of everything. From a classic shrimp and scallops combination to a seafood extravaganza featuring lobster, crab, and fish, our platters are designed to delight your taste buds and leave you feeling satisfied. They are perfect for sharing with friends and family and guarantee a delightful feast.

groumet seafood platter on wooden plate

Drinks and Beverages

Full Bar

To complement your seafood dining experience, Casey Key Fish House offers a full bar stocked with an extensive selection of beverages. From classic cocktails like margaritas and mojitos to refreshing rum punches and martinis, our skilled bartenders can whip up your favorite libations. Wine enthusiasts will also appreciate our carefully curated wine list, featuring a variety of options to pair perfectly with your meal.

Craft Beers

For beer connoisseurs, Casey Key Fish House also offers a variety of craft beers. We partner with local breweries to bring you a rotating selection of unique and flavorful beers. Whether you prefer a hoppy IPA, a smooth stout, or a refreshing wheat beer, we have something to suit every beer lover’s taste.

Wine Selection

To elevate your dining experience, our restaurant boasts an exceptional wine selection. Our wine list features a diverse range of varietals from around the world, carefully chosen to complement the flavors of our seafood dishes. Whether you are a fan of crisp and vibrant whites or prefer full-bodied and velvety reds, our friendly staff will be delighted to assist you in finding the perfect wine to enhance your meal.

Happy Hour and Daily Specials

Happy Hour Deals

Join us for our lively happy hour and take advantage of our enticing food and drink specials. Our happy hour is the perfect opportunity to unwind after a long day or gather with friends to start the evening on a high note. Enjoy discounted prices on select appetizers, cocktails, beer, and wine while soaking in the captivating views and vibrant atmosphere of Casey Key Fish House.

Daily Specials

In addition to our happy hour deals, we also offer daily specials to provide our guests with even more options to indulge in. From Monday to Sunday, our chefs create unique dishes that showcase the finest seasonal ingredients and innovative flavors. These specials are carefully crafted to deliver a culinary experience that is both exciting and satisfying, ensuring that each visit to Casey Key Fish House offers something new and delightful.

Outdoor Dining Experience

Relaxing Patio

One of the highlights of dining at Casey Key Fish House is our outdoor patio, where you can bask in the delightful Florida weather while enjoying your meal. With comfortable seating and ample shade, our patio offers a relaxing and inviting atmosphere. Immerse yourself in the tranquil surroundings as you dine with your loved ones or enjoy a leisurely meal by yourself.

Scenic Views

The outdoor dining experience at Casey Key Fish House comes with breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico. Whether it’s a stunning sunset or the sight of boats lazily sailing by on the Intracoastal Waterway, the natural beauty of the surroundings adds an extra touch of magic to your dining experience. Prepare to be captivated by the scenery as you savor our delicious seafood dishes.

Beach Access

If you’re looking to combine your dining experience with a little beach time, Casey Key Fish House has got you covered. Located just steps away from the pristine white sand beaches of Casey Key, our restaurant offers direct beach access for our guests. After enjoying a satisfying meal, you can take a leisurely stroll along the shore, soak up the sun, or even have a refreshing swim. It’s the perfect way to make the most of your visit to this beautiful area.

Customer Reviews

Positive Experiences

At Casey Key Fish House, we pride ourselves on creating memorable experiences for our customers. Many of our guests have left positive reviews, praising our delicious food, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere. They often mention the freshness of the seafood, the flavors that burst in their mouths, and the attentiveness of our staff. Our aim is to make every visit to our restaurant a delightful and satisfying one, and it is heartwarming to receive such positive feedback from our valued customers.

Accolades and Awards

Our commitment to excellence has not gone unnoticed, as Casey Key Fish House has received numerous accolades and awards throughout the years. We have been recognized for our outstanding seafood dishes, exceptional service, and dedication to providing a unique and enjoyable dining experience. These accolades serve as a testament to our unwavering commitment to quality and our passion for delivering the best seafood in town.

Critiques and Improvements

While we strive to provide an exceptional dining experience, we also value feedback from our customers that highlights areas where we can improve. Constructive critiques help us to continuously refine our offerings and enhance the overall experience for our guests. Rest assured that we take all feedback seriously and use it as an opportunity to learn and grow. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we are always working to exceed your expectations.

Casey Key Fish House: A Guide to the Restaurant

Reservation and Contact Information


To ensure that you have a seamless dining experience at Casey Key Fish House, we recommend making a reservation in advance. Our restaurant can get quite busy, especially during peak hours and weekends, and making a reservation guarantees you a table at your preferred date and time. Whether you are planning a romantic dinner for two or a gathering with friends and family, our friendly staff will be more than happy to assist you with your reservation.

Contact Details

Should you have any questions or need further information about Casey Key Fish House, our contact details are as follows:

  • Phone: [Phone Number]
  • Email: [Email Address]
  • Website: [Website URL]

Our dedicated team is available to answer any inquiries you may have, provide additional details about our menu or services, and assist you with making a reservation. We look forward to hearing from you and welcoming you to our restaurant.

Private Events and Catering

Private Parties

Casey Key Fish House is the ideal venue for private parties and special events. Whether you are planning a birthday celebration, a rehearsal dinner, a corporate gathering, or any other occasion worth celebrating, our restaurant can cater to your needs. We offer customizable menus to suit your preferences and can accommodate both intimate gatherings and larger groups. Our attentive staff will work closely with you to ensure that every detail of your event is executed flawlessly, leaving you and your guests with unforgettable memories.

Customized Menus

When it comes to private events and catering, we understand that every occasion is unique. That’s why Casey Key Fish House offers customized menus tailored to your specific requirements. Our talented chefs are happy to work with you to create a menu that perfectly complements your event and delights your guests. From seafood buffets to plated dinners, our culinary team will go above and beyond to exceed your expectations and ensure a truly exceptional dining experience.

Casey Key Fish House: A Guide to the Restaurant

Community Involvement

Local Support

At Casey Key Fish House, we deeply value our community and strive to give back in any way we can. We proudly support local fishermen and farmers by sourcing fresh and quality ingredients from them, helping to sustain and promote the local economy. Additionally, we actively collaborate with other businesses in the area to create a vibrant and interconnected community that benefits residents and visitors alike. By choosing to dine at Casey Key Fish House, you are not just enjoying a delicious meal but also contributing to the growth and prosperity of our beloved community.

Environmental Initiatives

As a coastal restaurant, we understand the importance of preserving and protecting the environment. We take pride in implementing sustainable practices throughout our operations, such as responsibly sourcing our seafood and minimizing waste. We are committed to reducing our carbon footprint and promoting eco-friendly initiatives within our establishment. By prioritizing sustainability, we aim to ensure that the natural beauty of Casey Key and its surrounding waters can be enjoyed for generations to come.

Staff and Service

Friendly and Knowledgeable Staff

One of the cornerstones of Casey Key Fish House is our exceptional staff. From the moment you step into our restaurant, you will be greeted by warm smiles and friendly faces. Our team is passionate about providing top-notch service and creating a pleasant and enjoyable atmosphere for our guests. They are well-versed in our menu selections and are more than happy to assist you in navigating through the various options, offering recommendations, and catering to any dietary preferences or allergies you may have.

Efficient Service

Prompt and efficient service is something we take great pride in at Casey Key Fish House. We understand that your time is valuable, so our team works diligently to ensure that your meals are served promptly and that all your needs are attended to. We strive to strike the right balance between attentiveness and allowing you to enjoy your dining experience at your own pace. Whether it’s refilling your drinks, answering your questions, or accommodating any special requests, our staff is dedicated to making your time with us seamless and enjoyable.

In conclusion, Casey Key Fish House offers a truly exceptional seafood dining experience. From the rich history and inviting ambiance to the delectable menu and attentive service, every aspect of our restaurant has been carefully curated to create an unforgettable experience for our guests. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast, a lover of stunning views, or simply seeking a friendly and relaxed atmosphere, Casey Key Fish House is the place to be. Join us today and embark on a culinary journey filled with fresh catches, delightful flavors, and cherished memories.

Casey Key Fish House: A Guide to the Restaurant

What do you think?

Written by saltyboatingADM

Casey Key Fish House: A Photo Gallery

Great views from Casey Key Fish House at lunch.

Casey Key Fish House: A Must-Visit for Seafood Lovers